I don’t envy anyone in the United States right now

I honestly don’t envy anyone in the United States right now. As if a phenomenally botched coronavirus-response wasn’t bad enough. But I guess this is what happens after decades, nay centuries of internal division.

Wasn’t diversity supposed to be what is great about the US? Growing up, the only question that seemed to matter was “melting pot” vs “salad bowl”. In other words, it only seemed to matter how the diversity expressed itself, not if diversity was or should be a thing.

But I guess even then it was all a lie. Even then, all that talk about freedom, liberty and unalienable rights came with an unspoken asterisk attached to it. Because even then, you had better be white, or eat shit.

If even I, as a guy white as the winter’s snow who doesn’t even live in the US, can see this so clearly, then how inconceivably suffocating must it be to find yourself at the sharp end of the racism stick? It honestly boggles the mind. No, I don’t envy anyone in the United States right now.

I am seeing several things, though.

First, nobody should be surprised at this. Decades, even centuries of division, coupled with economic hardship and active suppression by the state – what else could anyone expect? Yes, not all police are bad. It is a few bad apples. But a few bad apples spoil the bunch. Especially if you just leave the bad apples in the basket and reflexively spout “all lives matter” instead. Yes, all lives should matter. But they demonstrably do not. That is why people are protesting.

Second, the division is not unintentional. A few years ago, I read an article on the history of racism in the United States. The gist of it basically was: Thanks to racism, the poor hated each other instead of organizing against the rich. Racism distracted from economic inequality. It seems not much has changed.

Third, racism concerns everyone. The US prides itself in being a free market, democratic society. Neither of these two things work with racism. This is an online blog post, not a textbook, so I will keep this short: Racism leads to unequal access to the market, which means there is no free market. Racism also curtails free and open deliberation in the public sphere, which means there is no democracy.

Fourth, solutions are simple, but not easy. Removing systemic racism requires societal, economic, and institutional change. Identifying the issues is not hard. Implementing them in a sustainable way is. Effective leadership is needed. Unfortunately, neither the racist nor the senile grandpa you can likely choose between in November will be up to the task.

Fifth, there is hope. Even in these trying times, actions of solidarity and empathy outweigh everything else. Peaceful evolution of the United States is still possible in spite, or even because of all the crises it faces right now. Crises such as these can either show the way into a better future or plunge a country into bloody revolution. You, the People, will decide.

13 thoughts on “I don’t envy anyone in the United States right now

  1. The quantity of white Americans who do not believe racism exists is truly astounding. Many also can’t comprehend that they don’t see it because they are the ones benefitting from it. Makes me CRAZY!!

    Like

    1. Yes. Understanding that you just don’t understand is not easy, I guess. I certainly don’t understand, but I hope that the movements in the US will make a lasting, positive difference in society.

      Like

      1. I think they resulted in about 1cm of progress on a 1000km path. More if Biden picks a black running mate. More, again, if he gets elected (sadly, I think cheeto is going to win again).

        Like

            1. It is, and it is dangerous, no sense in downplaying that. They are also a clear minority, though, even more so than when he first got elected. Making a stand at the ballot box is still the single most effective thing everyone can do. Even things like gerrymandering can only go so far. There is a reason why the administration wants to make voting as hard as possible for many. If anyone wants to make a stand, make it there.

              Like

              1. He’s already setting up plans to contest mail in ballots (despite voting that way himself). Plus they’re screwing with the pistal service by inderfunding, understaffing, and eliminating OT (I haven’t had reliable service in months). California has already said that, due to C19, voting will be mail-in only. So a storm’s brewing!

                Like

                1. Yes, you are right to think that it is super dangerous. Hopefully the people will remain active and vigilant, and the system of checks and balances can still prove effective in containing something like this.

                  Like

  2. Wow! I have about 10 pages worth of comments! I agree with much of what you say and I especially appreciate well-stated post! These are the topics that cry out for reason and clear heads.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: